Review of ‘Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf’ (Soho Place, 2026): “Billy Crudup and Gillian Anderson are the hottest hot mess in town”

She’s finally done it. She’s no longer flat and boring as when she portrayed the nagging nonbeliever Dana Scully. And she isn’t the inaccurate caricature she played as Margaret Thatcher in The Crown. I must say I am really shocked. Surprised might be the word. And I shall add “pleasantly” to the description. Here comes a role that Gillian Anderson does justice to, and where she actually shines.

It might be the material’s exceptional quality. It might be a symptom of artistic maturity. Maybe it’s Marianne Elliot’s impeccable direction. Or it might be a combination of factors added to the low expectations I had when I returned to the Soho Place last night — for the press night of Edward Albee’s done-to-death play. Whatever it is, this latest production works like clockwork — the machinery isn’t completely broken in, but it will. And when that happens, it’ll be an explosion of theatrical viscerality.

Indeed, the play doesn’t have the same impact it did in its original days. The idea of the perfect, happy marriage (a cornerstone of all-American traditional values) is challenged and shredded to bits. George and Martha are unhappy. Extremely unhappy. Their loveless, toxic relationship is an active minefield waiting to detonate any minute. And it does constantly and savagely — with its blast wave sweeping away everything and everyone in the way.

Three and a half hours of delicious satire packed with stinging wit and brutal honesty. Albee’s genius remains intact overall. As a society, we might have grown to be more outspoken about these issues. Or at least, the need to put on a facade to cover a dysfunctional union is no longer crucial. Then again, social media culture would beg to differ.

That’s precisely what makes Albee’s writing so bitingly sharp. Even if the production preserves its 1960s essence, with the costume and set designs going for those aesthetics, its themes haven’t lost their resonance and relevance: the frustration of seeing your life trapped in a dead end; the urge to restore one’s dominance and sense of self-importance; rage, suffering, contention, and revenge colliding all at once; and the contradictory phenomenon of still caring for somebody who would only repay you with disdain and abuse. These are all fundamental parts of the human spirit, and the script does a brilliant job of speaking to each one.

Elliot’s direction provides the right dose of camp and self-possession, enhancing the piece’s dry humour and effectiveness. All the characters are exaggerated portrayals. By the time the show starts, George and Martha are already snapping, and despite the play’s length, things spiral out of control incredibly fast. Yet its credibility never wears off, nor does its ability to compel.

The design isn’t innovative, but it’s efficient nevertheless. Staged in the round, Miriam Buetcher’s set comprises a circular living room framed with bookshelves. The furniture sits on a revolving platform that slowly rotates as the second act unfurls, perhaps suggesting how things in the personages’ lives (particularly the guest couple, Nick and Honey) are getting out of place — and out of hand. In addition, a ring of screens ascends curtain-like as the performance resumes, going back down as George sinks into his own pit of despair.

The rest of the company is just as competent as Anderson, whose only flaw is a tiny lack of extra vulnerability the moment her character begins to crack, demonstrating technique but not complete authenticity. Billy Crudup has redeemed himself from his insipid performance in High Noon earlier this year (not that anything in that show was any better), admittedly becoming the strongest member of the cast — playing a delightfully ironic and deeply layered George.

The scepticism about bringing back this classic roughly a decade after its last West End revival is valid, but it should fade. An absolute tour de force, Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf is an overwhelming display of craftsmanship that delivers nothing but theatre at its best. It’s raw, frank, and thought-provoking. Truth or illusion? We might not know the difference. But anyway, it’s captivating.

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Help us continue our work

We count on your support to keep bringing the greatest quality in theatre-related content, from interviews with the biggest names in the industry to reviews of every show in town and beyond.

We appreciate every donation to maintain our high pace and standards and continue to grow.

Thank you for believing in us!

***************************************************

All pictures credit to Johan Persson.

Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf plays at London’s Soho Place until 19 December. Tickets are available on the following link.

By Guillermo Nazara

Leave a Reply